Are you really going to say that I imagined all of the old rules lawyering topics on the old site, just so that you don't need to feel wrong?
If you're to take the word of someone, would you rather go with the person who has actual experience with those old debate topics and is otherwise autistically obsessed with this website philosophy as a passion project, or from people who didn't even read the discussions to the point of forgetting that they existed at all?
And you want us to take the word of someone who is a proven reactionary, was "away" from SC for a long time and argues they know everything about the dox policy yet barely remembers what happened to Cad? ~
Honestly though, you could be right that the old consensus, way back, was closer to your version. I believe that consensus has evolved slightly over the years however, as a response to a new demographic and new events. We're obviously at odds here about the policy so it does nothing to whine about what we think it should be like (or that the mods are trying to change it behind the scenes). Better to focus on building a new consensus.
I propose we type out a neutral tldr background that doesn't confuse people and simply let them vote for their preferred choice.