Message Turncoat in a DM to get moderator attention

Users Online(? lurkers):
10 / 52 posts
Posts: 806
0 votes RE: South Korea Destabilized by Capitalism/North Korea Higher Birth...
kuhne said: 
 What? no utopia where you can play video games all day with no rent?

 You can become disabled like me and live on a disability pension. No need to work. I don't play computer games anymore, but I watch YouTube videos all day long.

Dima79
Posts: 295
0 votes RE: South Korea Destabilized by Capitalism/North Korea Higher Birth...
kuhne said: 

Dragoon would love the Soviet Union, he would get free rent and would not work. Exactly what causes communism to fail. Basically lazy freeloaders want communism.

kuhne said: 

 What? no utopia where you can play video games all day with no rent?

Chatgpt, can you analyze the fallacies in these two statements?

"Absolutely! Let's analyze the fallacies in K's statements step by step.


1. First Statement
"Dragoon would love the Soviet Union, he would get free rent and would not work. Exactly what causes communism to fail. Basically lazy freeloaders want communism."
a. Strawman Fallacy
Definition: Misrepresenting someone's argument to make it easier to attack.
In the statement: K attributes an oversimplified and distorted view of communism to you (Dragoon), implying that it is all about "free rent" and "not working." This caricature of communism sidesteps more nuanced discussions about its actual principles or history.
b. Ad Hominem Fallacy
Definition: Attacking the person rather than addressing their argument.
In the statement: K calls you a "lazy freeloader" instead of engaging with your perspective on communism. This personal attack does not contribute to the debate but seeks to discredit you directly.
c. Hasty Generalization
Definition: Drawing a conclusion based on insufficient evidence.
In the statement: K assumes that communism fails purely because of "lazy freeloaders," a sweeping generalization that ignores historical, economic, and social complexities of why different communist states succeeded or failed.

2. Second Statement
"What? No utopia where you can play video games all day with no rent?"
a. Red Herring Fallacy
Definition: Introducing an irrelevant point to distract from the main issue.
In the statement: K pivots to a caricature of a "video game utopia" to sidetrack the conversation, avoiding meaningful engagement with the historical or systemic realities of the USSR that were mentioned.
b. Appeal to Ridicule
Definition: Mocking an idea to discredit it instead of addressing its substance.
In the statement: K sarcastically ridicules the notion of a "utopia" where someone could play video games all day without rent. This does not contribute to the discussion but dismisses your argument as absurd without refuting it.
c. False Dichotomy
Definition: Presenting only two options as if they are the only possibilities.
In the statement: K implies that the only possible views of the USSR are either (1) an unattainable utopia or (2) the flawed system K associates with communism, leaving no room for more nuanced interpretations or critiques.

Summary of Fallacies
First Statement: Strawman, Ad Hominem, Hasty Generalization.
Second Statement: Red Herring, Appeal to Ridicule, False Dichotomy.
Both statements oversimplify complex topics and rely on fallacious reasoning rather than thoughtful critique or evidence-based discussion. They prioritize mockery and personal attacks over substantive argumentation."

Imperfect Priest of Determinism
last edit on 12/6/2024 4:38:44 PM
Posts: 62
0 votes RE: South Korea Destabilized by Capitalism/North Korea Higher Birth...
kuhne said: 

Dragoon would love the Soviet Union, he would get free rent and would not work. Exactly what causes communism to fail. Basically lazy freeloaders want communism.

kuhne said: 

 What? no utopia where you can play video games all day with no rent?





1. First Statement
"Dragoon would love the Soviet Union, he would get free rent and would not work. Exactly what causes communism to fail. Basically lazy freeloaders want communism."
a. Strawman Fallacy
Definition: Misrepresenting someone's argument to make it easier to attack.
In the statement: K attributes an oversimplified and distorted view of communism to you (Dragoon), implying that it is all about "free rent" and "not working." This caricature of communism sidesteps more nuanced discussions about its actual principles or history.
b. Ad Hominem Fallacy
Definition: Attacking the person rather than addressing their argument.
In the statement: K calls you a "lazy freeloader" instead of engaging with your perspective on communism. This personal attack does not contribute to the debate but seeks to discredit you directly.
c. Hasty Generalization
Definition: Drawing a conclusion based on insufficient evidence.
In the statement: K assumes that communism fails purely because of "lazy freeloaders," a sweeping generalization that ignores historical, economic, and social complexities of why different communist states succeeded or failed.

2. Second Statement
"What? No utopia where you can play video games all day with no rent?"
a. Red Herring Fallacy
Definition: Introducing an irrelevant point to distract from the main issue.
In the statement: K pivots to a caricature of a "video game utopia" to sidetrack the conversation, avoiding meaningful engagement with the historical or systemic realities of the USSR that were mentioned.
b. Appeal to Ridicule
Definition: Mocking an idea to discredit it instead of addressing its substance.
In the statement: K sarcastically ridicules the notion of a "utopia" where someone could play video games all day without rent. This does not contribute to the discussion but dismisses your argument as absurd without refuting it.
c. False Dichotomy
Definition: Presenting only two options as if they are the only possibilities.
In the statement: K implies that the only possible views of the USSR are either (1) an unattainable utopia or (2) the flawed system K associates with communism, leaving no room for more nuanced interpretations or critiques.

Summary of Fallacies
First Statement: Strawman, Ad Hominem, Hasty Generalization.
Second Statement: Red Herring, Appeal to Ridicule, False Dichotomy.
Both statements oversimplify complex topics and rely on fallacious reasoning rather than thoughtful critique or evidence-based discussion. They prioritize mockery and personal attacks over substantive argumentation."

So lazy you get an AI to talk for you.

last edit on 12/8/2024 1:26:35 AM
Posts: 62
0 votes RE: South Korea Destabilized by Capitalism/North Korea Higher Birth...

Looks like the highest birth rate for a country is in central Africa. Maybe you should go there. By your logic, that's the best place to be.

Posts: 817
0 votes RE: South Korea Destabilized by Capitalism/North Korea Higher Birth...
kuhne said: 
kuhne said: 

Dragoon would love the Soviet Union, he would get free rent and would not work. Exactly what causes communism to fail. Basically lazy freeloaders want communism.

kuhne said: 

 What? no utopia where you can play video games all day with no rent?





1. First Statement
"Dragoon would love the Soviet Union, he would get free rent and would not work. Exactly what causes communism to fail. Basically lazy freeloaders want communism."
a. Strawman Fallacy
Definition: Misrepresenting someone's argument to make it easier to attack.
In the statement: K attributes an oversimplified and distorted view of communism to you (Dragoon), implying that it is all about "free rent" and "not working." This caricature of communism sidesteps more nuanced discussions about its actual principles or history.
b. Ad Hominem Fallacy
Definition: Attacking the person rather than addressing their argument.
In the statement: K calls you a "lazy freeloader" instead of engaging with your perspective on communism. This personal attack does not contribute to the debate but seeks to discredit you directly.
c. Hasty Generalization
Definition: Drawing a conclusion based on insufficient evidence.
In the statement: K assumes that communism fails purely because of "lazy freeloaders," a sweeping generalization that ignores historical, economic, and social complexities of why different communist states succeeded or failed.

2. Second Statement
"What? No utopia where you can play video games all day with no rent?"
a. Red Herring Fallacy
Definition: Introducing an irrelevant point to distract from the main issue.
In the statement: K pivots to a caricature of a "video game utopia" to sidetrack the conversation, avoiding meaningful engagement with the historical or systemic realities of the USSR that were mentioned.
b. Appeal to Ridicule
Definition: Mocking an idea to discredit it instead of addressing its substance.
In the statement: K sarcastically ridicules the notion of a "utopia" where someone could play video games all day without rent. This does not contribute to the discussion but dismisses your argument as absurd without refuting it.
c. False Dichotomy
Definition: Presenting only two options as if they are the only possibilities.
In the statement: K implies that the only possible views of the USSR are either (1) an unattainable utopia or (2) the flawed system K associates with communism, leaving no room for more nuanced interpretations or critiques.

Summary of Fallacies
First Statement: Strawman, Ad Hominem, Hasty Generalization.
Second Statement: Red Herring, Appeal to Ridicule, False Dichotomy.
Both statements oversimplify complex topics and rely on fallacious reasoning rather than thoughtful critique or evidence-based discussion. They prioritize mockery and personal attacks over substantive argumentation."

So lazy you get an AI to talk for you.

He prompted the Ai to assume fallacies were at play, so the Ai assumed he wasn't any of those things when really, he isn't really going anywhere in life, because capitalism, not socialism.

Though he obviously utilizes some socialised aspects in life, being mentally disabled and all. 

Posts: 76
0 votes RE: South Korea Destabilized by Capitalism/North Korea Higher Birth...
kuhne said: 





1. First Statement
"Dragoon would love the Soviet Union, he would get free rent and would not work. Exactly what causes communism to fail. Basically lazy freeloaders want communism."
a. Strawman Fallacy
Definition: Misrepresenting someone's argument to make it easier to attack.
In the statement: K attributes an oversimplified and distorted view of communism to you (Dragoon), implying that it is all about "free rent" and "not working." This caricature of communism sidesteps more nuanced discussions about its actual principles or history.
b. Ad Hominem Fallacy
Definition: Attacking the person rather than addressing their argument.
In the statement: K calls you a "lazy freeloader" instead of engaging with your perspective on communism. This personal attack does not contribute to the debate but seeks to discredit you directly.
c. Hasty Generalization
Definition: Drawing a conclusion based on insufficient evidence.
In the statement: K assumes that communism fails purely because of "lazy freeloaders," a sweeping generalization that ignores historical, economic, and social complexities of why different communist states succeeded or failed.

2. Second Statement
"What? No utopia where you can play video games all day with no rent?"
a. Red Herring Fallacy
Definition: Introducing an irrelevant point to distract from the main issue.
In the statement: K pivots to a caricature of a "video game utopia" to sidetrack the conversation, avoiding meaningful engagement with the historical or systemic realities of the USSR that were mentioned.
b. Appeal to Ridicule
Definition: Mocking an idea to discredit it instead of addressing its substance.
In the statement: K sarcastically ridicules the notion of a "utopia" where someone could play video games all day without rent. This does not contribute to the discussion but dismisses your argument as absurd without refuting it.
c. False Dichotomy
Definition: Presenting only two options as if they are the only possibilities.
In the statement: K implies that the only possible views of the USSR are either (1) an unattainable utopia or (2) the flawed system K associates with communism, leaving no room for more nuanced interpretations or critiques.

Summary of Fallacies
First Statement: Strawman, Ad Hominem, Hasty Generalization.
Second Statement: Red Herring, Appeal to Ridicule, False Dichotomy.
Both statements oversimplify complex topics and rely on fallacious reasoning rather than thoughtful critique or evidence-based discussion. They prioritize mockery and personal attacks over substantive argumentation."

So lazy you get an AI to talk for you.

He prompted the Ai to assume fallacies were at play, so the Ai assumed he wasn't any of those things when really, he isn't really going anywhere in life, because capitalism, not socialism.

Though he obviously utilizes some socialised aspects in life, being mentally disabled and all. 

 What are you, as a person, if you were to leave behind the memes?

No "women this", "politics that", "money the other one", who do you reckon you'd be?

Posts: 817
0 votes RE: South Korea Destabilized by Capitalism/North Korea Higher Birth...
EpsilonMale said:

What are you, as a person, if you were to leave behind the memes?

No "women this", "politics that", "money the other one", who do you reckon you'd be?

 You'll have to elaborate more on your question. What do you know about my views on women, politics, and I don't understand what "money the other one" means. 

 A simple answer would be, I'd be myself with the exception of those things. What do you think ?

Posts: 295
0 votes RE: South Korea Destabilized by Capitalism/North Korea Higher Birth...

The ai never made any positive or negative assumptions about me. learn what a fallacy is. Point is, you/kuhne attacked me as a way to attack my argument/views, which is a fallacy.

"K calls you a "lazy freeloader" instead of engaging with your perspective on communism. This personal attack does not contribute to the debate but seeks to discredit you directly."
Lol this is not making a personal positive or negative assumptions about me, it's simply pointing out your fallacy.

Imperfect Priest of Determinism
last edit on 12/8/2024 2:25:51 AM
Posts: 62
-1 votes RE: South Korea Destabilized by Capitalism/North Korea Higher Birth...

The ai never made any positive or negative assumptions about me. learn what a fallacy is. Point is, you/kuhne attacked me as a way to attack my argument/views, which is a fallacy.

"K calls you a "lazy freeloader" instead of engaging with your perspective on communism. This personal attack does not contribute to the debate but seeks to discredit you directly."
Lol this is not making a personal positive or negative assumptions about me, it's simply pointing out your fallacy.

This is why you are drawn to the fake utopia, you're a lazy freeloader that wants to leech off the system.

Where in capitalism, you are rewarded for hard work. And you call this slavery.

Then Dima tells you communism puts freeloaders in jail.  Hmmmm

The insult is relevant to the discussion showing that freeloaders are easy to manipulate into revolution. And are thus the useful idiots.

last edit on 12/8/2024 6:08:05 PM
Posts: 295
0 votes RE: South Korea Destabilized by Capitalism/North Korea Higher Birth...

In Capitalism people are not rewarded for work, hard or not.

Imperfect Priest of Determinism
last edit on 12/8/2024 6:38:01 PM
10 / 52 posts
This site contains NSFW material. To view and use this site, you must be 18+ years of age.