I recently talked to some members about the state of the forum and the quality of the content. The consensus was that while the freedom of this forum is appealing it also suffocates meaningful discussions through spam and keeps people from putting effort into threads and posts.
We had a lot of debate about the question of moderation in the past and the main argument against moderation was that the forum shouldn't turn into a heavily moderated place like the other mental health forums. Also nobody liked the idea of someone having too much power.
I think a good middle way would be to give thread creators mod powers so that they can prevent their own threads from derailing.
Possible Mod powers:
o The thread creator can hide single posts. Members don't see hidden posts by default but get the option to unhide single or all posts in a thread.
o It can be chosen between a blacklist, whilelist or no list at all. Which approach is used can be still changed after thread creation.
Blacklist: Everyone can post except members on the blacklist.
Since it's very easy to create new accounts one would also need the feature to blacklist all accounts that got created after a certain point in time.
Whitelist: Nobody can post except people on the whitelist.
The whitelist is interesting because it would enable members to create blog-like threads where they could only post for themselves or a few select others. That might compensate for the lack of profile functions.
Concerns:
o Certain Members might get blacklisted in most threads.
I guess if that happens it happens for a good reason.
o Thread creators will misuse their power.
That will happen but in general I think people are more interested in input than keeping people from answering their threads.
If there are some members who like to mess around on a regular basis won't affect the rest of the forum.
Advantages:
o No centralized mod power. No rule set for the whole forum.
o The possibility to keep threads from becoming off-topic will encourage people to invest more time and effort.
o There's still place for the usual drama and unmoderated talk.
o Every account is equal.
Any thoughts on this idea?