by Luna Prey
That being said, I do sometimes wish the community could be a bit more intellectual. I think in the future, perhaps a moderated sub-community with an ephasis on intellectual discussion and a bit more formal setting could allow the more serious types a place to discuss the topic without having to deal with trolls.
If the site continues to grow at the rate it has been, then it's inevitable that there will have to be sub-forums, or different boards for different topics. I don't agree with moderation (except in the three instances that Alter mentioned), but the current design is best suited to a smaller community. I thought the old forum was pretty cool – and I don't think that can be just nostalgia in my case, as I was only posting there for a short time – but as Luna said, this place is almost twice the size, and as a result has a different atmosphere.
I think the problem at the moment is that there is a hardcore group of individuals who spend their every waking moment on here, in some cases creating armies of puppets. I know this was the case on the old forum too, but now when you combine that with the sheer volume of other posters and the speed at which topics are being created and commented on, it is impossible to keep up. I enjoy the puppet games as much as anyone, but with the current size of the forum I reckon it would take over an hour a day of thread reading and chat lurking to truly get a handle on who everybody is and what's going on, and not everyone has that amount of free time.
Not that I blame Luna for wanting to grow and monetize the forum. If I were investing my time and money into running this place I would be doing exactly the same. But perhaps we are getting to a stage where the trolls are having a domino effect, and more are being attracted while the kind of people who would have posted on the old forum are being put off.
The real issue here is the size of the place, and there must be ways other than moderation with which to deal with that.
I remember this one time I agreed to watch a scary movie. Ever since, I've been afraid to go into our attic because I'm afraid I'll see that grudge creature.
Aww. Don't mean to sound patronising, but that's so cute!