No no this one is in itself still self demonstrative; Rather than giving them what's good for them, you're giving them something they want over the social expectation.
Im giving them whats good for them, so its not that "Im rather not giving them whats good for them."
A better example would be my wife wanting jewelry. Jewelry is pointless, so I plan a joint trip for us to Japan or somewehere else instead. Its significantly more useful. People who travel are almost immune to joblessness.
Traveling is expensive though, especially to Japan, and this sounds like when people buy a gift as a way for someone to selfishly give it to themselves. Does she even like traveling, or is this being insisted on her like a Halloween Toothbrush?
Still an opportunity to buy Japanese Jewelry as a souvenir though; Best of both worlds.
We both hate traveling but it's good for our characters so I do it.
Or my friend has a broken phone, so I buy her a phone.
Which is an opportunity to get a quirky one that they'd love, like getting the earlier hypothetical person a Totoro Phone rather than a plain one.
I see no need for a Totoro Phone. Why does she need a Totoro phone? Give me a reason.
Or a tooth replacement. I dont know why Id buy them stuff like dresses. Totally pointless, they'll forget it in 5 seconds.
Every time they wear it they'll remember who got it for them, rendering it only pointless if there aren't positive associations with the gift.
Until they get a new dress. They wont get rid of the tooth so easily, they'll think of me whenever they eat, i.e., when they are reminded of the tooth job.
On a more serious note, that's not the point. The point is more that dresses play into people's desires in a way that is counter productive for their character growth. Its very materialistic. Its not going to help them.
You have use for a few things, emotional attachment/religious things, functional things (e.g. computer or a wallet), and basic necessities (nutritious food). The rest is materialistic garbage.
Also, you should prioritize low cost and long life in any purchase over prestige/brand name.
Always buy them things they "need" and not what they "want".
Gifts are an indulgence, and the occasional indulgence is what someone needs.
It's possible to 'need' a 'want'.
Yes if its one of those 3 things I listed. Otherwise no.
Since when was indulgence a "need"?