Rose tattoo is an orangey red wheras on occasions I wo wear red I prefer burgundy or a true red. This color would likely also be reserved for fall-leaf looks or costume make up.
Ocean ave is pretty. I could see that as a njce lid shade witha smoked brown crease, or to add shimmer to the center of the lid over another color
Tan lines are toasty are the two colors that would likely get much use, as I said i often wish I had some medium matte browns. Toasty is kinda warm toned though and a cool town brown would likely get more use with my make up habits
Puppy love is a pretty one, and venice fling. I could see using either of these for the outer corners or maybe even puppy love on the lid if I'm going for bold