Message Turncoat in a DM to get moderator attention

Users Online(? lurkers):
10 / 34 posts
0 votes

I think that materialism is a great thing.


Posts: 2230

I do not understand the purpose of this backlash against liking new stuff and wanting nice things in modern society. Materialism is a great motivator for people to go out and consume, which makes the people selling it to you and their employees have more money, and if you have a job that means YOU too. Additionally, materialism gives everyone a unique style. No two consumers are EXACTLY the same, everyone has a unique swagger and part of how we express this individualism is to consume for materials that we feel represent us. I'd argue that if anything it helps interpersonal human connection, as people can bond over the materials they consume. Materialism is rad.

My grandiose delusions are better than yours.
Posts: 894
0 votes RE: I think that materialis...

 

maybe if it consumes you and its all you think about. that would be bad. i like nice things. nothing wrong with that.

 

Posts: 248
0 votes RE: I think that materialis...

it's when you view history like that, when it becomes problematic. Vulgar materalism is synonymous with marxism and has led to the mass slaughter and turmoil of today's world.

regular materalism isn;t bad at all. we are always going to need things in this finite world. my question though is what is our alternative to narrating history if not through materials? we can grasp events like prayer beads or as constellations and I opt for the latter personally. Not to big into clutching mommas pearls.

timsecapsule.com
Posts: 2266
0 votes RE: I think that materialis...
enutsur said: 

it's when you view history like that, when it becomes problematic. Vulgar materalism is synonymous with marxism and has led to the mass slaughter and turmoil of today's world.

 Agreed. 

Though it is unfortunately synonymous with Marxism, which I deem to be unfair because it's a subset of a greater category of idealism, it is in actuality a consequence of French and Anglo rationalism. Marxism is none the less a great example, as is capitalism. 

Posts: 2230
0 votes RE: I think that materialis...

How is materialism at its extreme marxist

My grandiose delusions are better than yours.
Posts: 248
0 votes RE: I think that materialis...

it's not at an extreme. He twists it though to make humanity seem vulgar and detestable,

"A spirit is huanting Europe.. blah blah blah... the spirit of the proletariate"""

timsecapsule.com
Posts: 2230
0 votes RE: I think that materialis...
enutsur said: 

it's not at an extreme. He twists it though to make humanity seem vulgar and detestable,

"A spirit is huanting Europe.. blah blah blah... the spirit of the proletariate"""

 Communists have always struck me as jealous of others' success.

My grandiose delusions are better than yours.
Posts: 2266
0 votes RE: I think that materialis...

How is materialism at its extreme marxist

Marxism is a purely materialist philosophy. 

You must understand that materialism means two things, both of which are deeply intertwined. 

  1. Obsession with material (physical things made of matter) 
  2. Dismissal of theism (the transcendental)

Marxisms two fundamental ideas are that man is derived purely from physical nature and the materialist conception of history. The first is self explanatory, though Marx is very specific as it pertains to how theism arises in man (and these ideas are connected deeply with his philosophy of history). The second is what enutsur has touched upon and is essentially a view of world history and daily life in which all is a struggle for material, that is history is material. The fundamental thing that distinguishes Man from beat is his capacity to use matter to create material and that creation is the fundamental force behind social relations. 

That's the gist. 

last edit on 6/3/2019 4:25:22 AM
Posts: 2230
0 votes RE: I think that materialis...

How is materialism at its extreme marxist

Marxism is a purely materialist philosophy. 

You must understand that materialism means two thing, both of which are deeply intertwined. 

  1. Materialism is an obsession with material (physical things made of matter) 
  2. Dismissal of theism (the transcendental)

Marxisms two fundamental ideas are that man is derived purely from physical nature and the materialist conception of history. The first is self explanatory, though Marx is very specific as it pertains to how theism arises in man (and these ideas are connected deeply with his philosophy of history). The second is what enutsur has touched upon and is essentially a view of world history and daily life in which all is a struggle for material, that is history is material. The fundamental thing that distinguishes Man from beat is his capacity to use matter to create material and that creation is the fundamental force behind social relations. 

That's the gist. 

 Marx seems to despise materialism all the same, however. But I think that it is good and natural. I am biased though, look at my avatar.

My grandiose delusions are better than yours.
Posts: 2266
1 votes RE: I think that materialis...

How is materialism at its extreme marxist

Marxism is a purely materialist philosophy. 

You must understand that materialism means two thing, both of which are deeply intertwined. 

  1. Materialism is an obsession with material (physical things made of matter) 
  2. Dismissal of theism (the transcendental)

Marxisms two fundamental ideas are that man is derived purely from physical nature and the materialist conception of history. The first is self explanatory, though Marx is very specific as it pertains to how theism arises in man (and these ideas are connected deeply with his philosophy of history). The second is what enutsur has touched upon and is essentially a view of world history and daily life in which all is a struggle for material, that is history is material. The fundamental thing that distinguishes Man from beat is his capacity to use matter to create material and that creation is the fundamental force behind social relations. 

That's the gist. 

 Marx seems to despise materialism all the same, however. But I think that it is good and natural. I am biased though, look at my avatar.

 He does not despise materialism at all, he believes it is the one true important thing. 

He along with Smith are the most famous Materlialists in recent memory because they spent most of their lives endorsing it. Marx merely has a specific view on how materialism should work or rather how it does work - but more on that in a second. 

Marx was a massive fan of Hegel and is essentially a Hegelian who replaced Idealism with Materialism - keep in mind Idealism is transcendental which Marx rejects. Hegelianism is built on the idea of the dialectic which you have an extremely lay man knowledge of do to your study's in writing. The dialectic at a low level is built on the dynamic of thesis and antithesis and how these two things interact and lead into one another. The dialectic is the broad category and for Marx the broadest category that dictates human affairs is Materialism, hence it isn't something he loves or hate but if anything accepts as the fundamental human reality outside of nature. The thesis can be seen as capitalism, that which comes out of Smith, and the antithesis is Marxism which is what capitalism leads into. Hence, capitalism in this view is really the same thing as marxism because they are merely different stages of the same process. Marx calls this Dialectical Materialism. 

As a side note the dialectic is a trifecta, there's an added upward dimension called the synthesis but...that's complicated.  

  

last edit on 6/3/2019 5:08:12 PM
10 / 34 posts
This site contains NSFW material. To view and use this site, you must be 18+ years of age.