Message Turncoat in a DM to get moderator attention

Users Online(? lurkers):
10 / 59 posts

Coming off another thread ............ Made vs Genetics


Posts: 299

 

by Questioning_Life

 

by Breakthrough

How many people here got royally screwed up themselves as a result of that sort of thing?

 

She's a kid.

 ^^ I would venture to guess more people on this forum were "made" rather than born the way they are.  New thread coming 

 

Were you born the way you are? Or, were you made through childhood trauma?

 

 

 

Posts: 93
Coming off another thread ............ Made vs Genetics

 

by Questioning_Life

 

by Questioning_Life

 

by Breakthrough

How many people here got royally screwed up themselves as a result of that sort of thing?

 

She's a kid.

 ^^ I would venture to guess more people on this forum were "made" rather than born the way they are.  New thread coming 

 

Were you born the way you are? Or, were you made through childhood trauma?

 

 

 

 Genetics is a big part of it. That I know. How does a child know what trauma is when they don't any different?

And, I was a hell raiser as a kid.

Posts: 299
Coming off another thread ............ Made vs Genetics

Yes, genetics can predispose a person to many things but without the trauma would genetics have the same play in what a person becomes? (speaking about personality disorders)

Posts: 93
Coming off another thread ............ Made vs Genetics

Depend on the disorder by the looks of things. No clear cut answers it seems and some similarities.

Humans hurting humans and it gets so damn retarded .

Like the sex with the little girl in the sexy outfit. Who the heck would even dress their daughter up like that and then post a picture? She's a kid. 11-12 yrs old. WTF?

Posts: 285
Coming off another thread ............ Made vs Genetics

I wasn't born this way, but I agree, there was most likely a predisposition toward a pd. I was a fairly normal kid until the abuse started, the worse it got, the worse I got. Until I finally reached a point where I didn't care anymore. People, especially, became meaningless to me. I'm not a sociopath, or a raging killer. In fact, I take no pleasure in the suffering of others, but I don't care either, unless it's someone close to me.

Posts: 299
Coming off another thread ............ Made vs Genetics

 

by Breakthrough

Depend on the disorder by the looks of things. No clear cut answers it seems and some similarities.

Humans hurting humans and it gets so damn retarded .

Like the sex with the little girl in the sexy outfit. Who the heck would even dress their daughter up like that and then post a picture? She's a kid. 11-12 yrs old. WTF?

 You're assuming a parent dressed her up and took the picture and she's not a victim being made to do that.

I agree there are not clear cut answers. In my case I do believe it's a combination of both. Both parents are fucked as are their parents, or at least from what I have been told my biological mother's parents and sister are and I assume my father's parents as well.  Therefore I was certainly predisposed by genetics. Coupled with my childhood, there's my answer. 

It would be interesting to read about someone with no mental illness in their family and yes has a confirmed Dx. 

Posts: 34
Coming off another thread ............ Made vs Genetics

In my experience I believe it was a combination of both. Before the abuse from my father and the negligence of my mother to respond to needs as I child, I assume there was a time when I was a relatively normal neurotypical so to speak. However my father, whom I believed to be a narcissist, most likely played a role in passing on the apathetic gene down the line. My thinking tends to dictate that nature over nurture is the cause for the disorder, yet there is plenty of evidence to suggest otherwise; e.g. Not all the child soldiers in Africa are 'paths despite their horrific upbringings. So really it goes both ways in the development of p/s'paths.

Posts: 93
Coming off another thread ............ Made vs Genetics

 

by wahoo

I wasn't born this way, but I agree, there was most likely a predisposition toward a pd. I was a fairly normal kid until the abuse started, the worse it got, the worse I got. Until I finally reached a point where I didn't care anymore. People, especially, became meaningless to me. I'm not a sociopath, or a raging killer. In fact, I take no pleasure in the suffering of others, but I don't care either, unless it's someone close to me.

 Brutal. And last sentence , same. I wasn't abused, not like many kids. Knowing what it can do to people, that is what makes it a problem.

Posts: 299
Coming off another thread ............ Made vs Genetics

 

by Shatter

In my experience I believe it was a combination of both. Before the abuse from my father and the negligence of my mother to respond to needs as I child, I assume there was a time when I was a relatively normal neurotypical so to speak. However my father, whom I believed to be a narcissist, most likely played a role in passing on the apathetic gene down the line. My thinking tends to dictate that nature over nurture is the cause for the disorder, yet there is plenty of evidence to suggest otherwise; e.g. Not all the child soldiers in Africa are 'paths despite their horrific upbringings. So really it goes both ways in the development of p/s'paths.

 Agree completely but it's not limited to just AsPD, Psychopath, Sociopath etc.. 

Posts: 93
Coming off another thread ............ Made vs Genetics

The way I  look at it, it's not a crime against existence, but what you do about it. Not the end of the world but in my case, explained why I viewed the "world" the way I do and a few other things.

10 / 59 posts
This site contains NSFW material. To view and use this site, you must be 18+ years of age.