Peanut butter or jelly? I assume jelly is what a European would call jam. On what? Toast? If so, jam, on cold bread, PB.
Jelly or jam? It's called jam. Jelly is what you put beside your roast.
Strawberry jelly or grape jelly? They don't exist.
Strawberry jam or grape jam? Strawberry.
Peas or corn? Depends with what. Totally.
Peas with sugar or corn on the cob without butter? Corn of the cob.
Sugar or brown sugar? No thanks.
Oatmeal or cream of wheat? Oatmeal.
Pancakes or waffles? European pancakes.
McDonald's or Taco Bell? Since we don't have Taco Bell I have to choose McDonald's but the burgers suck and so do the fries so I'll choose something else.
Taco or burritos? Burritos. Although we don't use that word here.
Meat or no meat? No meat, usually.
Lasagna or Spaghetti? Spaghetti.
Spaghetti or Spaghetti with meatballs? Spaghetti. With meatballs.... such odd combo could only happen in USA.
Spaghettios or Raviolis? Ravioli is less gross.