Your turn, Turn. :)
A mix of instinct and deduction, Nini.
Ana, the first list comprises descriptors that come to mind when I think of the people on this forum. In the second, I forced myself to associate a potential emotion to the individuals in question. So I would say both, but the second list is more consistent with the stated purpose of this thread.
I edited yours to be more on point right before you commented.
Feelings sound so boring from me. I like the depth of stories, but what I feel seems so trivial by comparison. What the real dividing factor for me is is if they do or don't have my attention. I either barely notice them, they're noticed but I don't seem to care, they have my attention but don't seem to do much, they have my attention because of either from what they do or because they do a lot, they have my attention and I want to know more, or they have my attention to a weird degree even by my own understanding, so it's basically like a dimmer switch. Beyond that it's if they're a built up figure or someone newer and if I find aspects of them closer to my type.
I ought to revise it at some point to be better. Either that or I need to get to know some people a bit more so that I can have more creative word choices.