Message Turncoat in a DM to get moderator attention

Users Online(? lurkers):
8 posts

The Placebo Effect


Posts: 2358

You guys probably know what "the placebo effect" means.  I have recently heard and read that it is getting more difficult over time to surpass its effectiveness in drug testing.  Does anyone know about this or have any speculation with regard to this?  Either placebo is getting better than medicine, or drugs are getting worse.  It seems like the same thing, but the difference has a fairly large impact.

Posts: 10218
The Placebo Effect

Posts: 1286
The Placebo Effect

care to post a source? thats a very broad topic, are we talking pain reduction or cancer treatment?

Posts: 2358
The Placebo Effect

 

 Well, my interest stems from watching this: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2P0LGFkaaMA

He mentions it briefly, but I decided to just quickly look it up at Wikipedia.  I am reading through and come across:

A further issue of concern to pharmaceutical companies is that the effectiveness of placebos has increased over time,[197] thus making it more difficult to demonstrate the effectiveness of new drugs. The reason for the increased effectiveness is disputed.

(Under "Placebo-controlled Studies.")

So, I think the references are very very general.  I guess if there were specific differences between cancer treatments and pain, then there is obviously more depth to this than I already guessed.  I also wonder if it is specific to what the placebo is supposed to be simulating.  Is placebo pain-relief much easier to achieve than a cancer remission?  It seems a lot more sensible.  I'm curious about the entirety of the possibilities and the phenomena in general, wherever it is found that the placebo effect has become more effective than other treatments.

Posts: 1156
The Placebo Effect

 The placebo effect is often not tested properly. They often don't include a control group.

Posts: 2358
The Placebo Effect

 Hmm, at least in regard to drug testing, would the control for the placebo effect be the group taking the real drug?

Posts: 1156
The Placebo Effect

 No, the control should take nothing at all.

Posts: 2358
The Placebo Effect

 Ah yes, gotcha.  Agreed.

8 posts
This site contains NSFW material. To view and use this site, you must be 18+ years of age.