I know it's stupid, but I eat up paranormal video stuff... Like Nuke's Top 5, King Frostmare, Sir Spooks and this guy:
I'm a dufus and do this right before bed most of the time, too.
I know it's really fake, but there's some that I am kind of "wtf" about.
(The narrators are often weird and uncanny valley to some degree, as well.)
I can see the appeal. It's a retarded little guilty pleasure. I'm sure you're not alone.